This was a promising plot, and the author took an interesting approach. The cover is gorgeous, and the idea, fascinating; my takeaway from it all is that when I finished the book, I was....confused. I've been trying to write this review for some time and have struggled to articulate my thoughts, especially as I didn't want to give any spoilers. I think the bottom line is that I kept waiting for a clever connection point and didn't find it. (My disclaimer is that without choosing to re-read the entire book I'm not sure if I just missed it, or it simply wasn't there.)
Told through a series of emails, texts, and letters PLUS a manuscript - it's a lot! There are also two timelines: present day with Josie, who primarily emails with her friend Faith. She also texts with her mom, estate caretakers/surrogate grandparents, and Oliver. The second timeline is 200 years ago: a gentleman named Elias Roch has written letter after letter to the elusive Josephine (who has numerous similarities to our girl Josie). Elias has also written a novel, and I think that is where I got lost. I couldn't keep it straight between the Elias letters (reality) and his novel (not reality per se but....suggestive of something? Maybe? Again, it's possible that I missed the point entirely.)
There were definitely very cute moments and sweet spots in some of the relationships. Humor abounds. It just didn't seem to fully come together. Maybe you could read it and we could chat? Then you would be able to tell me if the book needed more editing or I am just lacking a little imagination. :)
I was provided a complimentary copy of this book from Thomas Nelson Publishers and NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.
No comments:
Post a Comment